MakeMKV Review & 5 Best MakeMKV Alternatives on Windows and Mac

MakeMKV is a great tool to convert DVDs to MKV files without losing quality. While it works for DVD ripping, users may encounter some problems, like the software not working properly or format incompatibility. So, many people look for the best MakeMKV alternatives. In this post, we’ll review MakeMKV, guide you through the DVD ripping process, pros and cons, and 5 top MakeMKV alternatives for your PC.

What is MakeMKV?

MakeMKV is a reliable and free DVD and Blu-ray ripper that decrypts protected discs and converts video from VOB or M2TS containers to MKV format without re-encoding or quality loss. As open-source software, it stands out for its simplicity, and consistent updates.

How to Use MakeMKV to Rip DVD

Ripping a DVD with MakeMKV is simple. Follow these steps to rip DVD with MakeMKV and convert your physical media into digital files:

Step 1: First, download and install MakeMKV on your computer. It’s available for Windows, Linux, and Mac, so follow the installation instructions for your system.

Step 2: Once MakeMKV is installed, insert the DVD you want to rip into your computer’s DVD drive.

Step 3: Now, open MakeMKV. The interface will show all the optical drives. To import your video, click on "File" and select "Open Files" or "Open Disc".

Step 4: Select the titles you want to save as MKV and the tracks you want to keep. Then, select the output folder and click the "Make MKV" button to start the conversion.

Pros and Cons of MakeMKV

Here are the advantages and disadvantages to help you decide if MakeMKV is for you.

Is MakeMKV Safe?

Safety and Trustworthiness

Yes, MakeMKV is safe to use. It’s a trusted software for DVD and Blu-ray ripping, and the official website guarantees that the software is free of spyware, adware, and viruses. However, always download from the official website to minimize risks.

MakeMKV Issues

While MakeMKV is safe, some users experience common issues. These are not security related but can affect the experience. Here are the most common MakeMKV problems:

• Can’t detect the optical drive.
• Long ripping time, some users take 5 hours to rip 4 Blu-ray movies and 3 DVDs.
• “Failed to Open Disc” errors.
• Limited format support, can only convert DVDs and Blu-rays to MKV.
• Can’t read the data on the physical disc.

Legal Considerations

Ripping DVDs and Blu-rays you own or created yourself is legal and safe. However, ripping protected DVDs or Blu-rays for commercial use is illegal. In some cases, ripping encrypted Blu-rays and DVDs for personal use is allowed, but varies by region.

Best MakeMKV Alternatives for DVD Ripping

MakeMKV is good for ripping DVDs and Blu-rays, but not for everyone. Depending on your needs, whether it’s faster ripping speed, more formats, or video editing, other software might be better. To help you choose a better one, let’s see some MakeMKV alternatives that offer a more robust DVD ripping experience.

DVDneXtCOPY DVD Ripper

• System Requirements: Windows 11/10/8.1/8/7 (32/64 bit)
• Price and Plans: $79.99 for lifetime license and 5PC
• Free Trial: 30 days

DVDneXtCOPY DVD Ripper is a great and feature-rich alternative to MakeMKV, offering a powerful and all-in-one solution for DVD ripping. When comparing DVDneXtCOPY vs MakeMKV, one of the main differences is that MakeMKV mainly focuses on converting DVDs to MKV format, while DVDneXtCOPY supports over 1000 audio and video formats, including MKV, AVI, MP4, MOV, and more. This gives users more options to choose from.

Also, this DVD Ripper has customizable video settings, high speed ripping, and supports both regular and copy-protected DVDs. Next, let’s see the pros and cons of using DVDneXtCOPY DVD Ripper for DVD ripping.

How to use DVDneXtCOPY DVD Ripper as an alternative to MakeMKV:

Step 1: Load Your DVD

• Launch DVDneXtCOPY program and select the Ripper Module.
• Insert the desired DVD into your optical drive, and the program will automatically detect and load the DVD.
• Alternatively, click the "+" button to manually load the DVD source, or drag and drop the DVD folder or file directly into the main interface.

Step 2: Choose Output Format and Customize Settings

• In the Profile Selection Box, choose the desired output format from the built-in profile library (e.g., MP4, MP3, MKV, AVI, etc.).

• If needed, customize your video by adjusting audio, subtitles, chapters, and other advanced settings.

• You can also use the built-in editor to make additional changes to the DVD content.

Step 3: Select Output Folder and Start the Ripping Process

• Choose the destination folder where you want to save the output video.
• Click Start to begin ripping the DVD, including any protected DVDs.

WinX DVD Ripper Platinum

• System Requirements: Windows 11/10/8.1/8/7/Vista/XP, macOS 10.5 - 13
• Price and Plans: $49.95 for 1-year license/ $65.95 for lifetime license
• Free Trial: No specific duration, but it only converts up to 5 minutes of each DVD.

Instead of MakeMKV, WinX DVD Ripper Platinum for Windows and Mac is a better way to digitize your DVDs for backup, editing, archiving, etc. Like MakeMKV, it supports DVDs, VIDEO_TS folder, and ISO files as input sources. With over 350 output profiles (including MKV), you can play your disc content on almost any device and player.

Plus, it can bypass general CSS encryption, UOPs, Sony ARccOS, APS, and RCE DVD copy protections. As an alternative to MakeMKV, WinX DVD Ripper Platinum has its own strengths and weaknesses. Here are the details.

How to use WinX DVD Ripper Platinum as a MakeMKV alternative:

Step 1: First, install and launch WinX DVD Ripper on your Windows or Mac computer.

Step 2: Open the program and click the DVD Disc icon to load your DVD into the software.

Step 3: Select the desired output format for the ripped DVD, either as a video file or device-specific format.

Step 4: Click Browse to choose a destination folder where you want to save the ripped DVD file.

Step 5: Once everything is set, click the RUN button to begin ripping the DVD, including protected DVDs.

HandBrake

• OS: Windows 10/8.1/7, macOS 10.13 and later，Linux
• Price: Free

Another option is HandBrake, a free, open-source video transcoder that works on Windows, Mac, and Linux. While MakeMKV is focused on DVD and Blu-ray conversion, HandBrake has built-in device presets so you can select profiles for specific devices or universal settings for standard or high quality conversions.

But, unlike MakeMKV, HandBrake can’t handle encrypted discs, so it won’t work with most commercial Blu-ray discs. To bypass DVD copy protections, you need to install the libdvdcss library with HandBrake.

Here are the pros and cons of Handbrake as MakeMKV alternative.

How to use HandBrake as an alternative to MakeMKV:

Step 1: Insert your target DVD into the DVD drive of your computer.

Step 2: Then launch HandBrake. The program will automatically detect the inserted DVD and display it in the Source Selection area.

Step 3: Click on the detected DVD. HandBrake will scan the content, which may take some time, depending on the size of the DVD.

Step 4: HandBrake will select a default title. To choose another, click the Title drop-down menu and select the desired one.

Step 5: Choose your output preset, customize video quality, audio tracks, and subtitles as needed.

Step 6: Select the destination folder for the ripped file and click the Start Encode button to begin the ripping process.

Wondershare UniConverter

• OS: Windows 11/10/8/7, macOS 10.13 and later
• Price and Plans: $29.99 for 1-year license/ $39.99 for lifetime license
• Free Trial: 7 days

As an alternative to MakeMKV, Wondershare UniConverter offers DVD digitization with more format support. In contrast to MakeMKV, which is mainly limited to MKV format, UniConverter supports almost all popular formats like MKV, MOV, MP4, M4V, etc. so, you have more playback options.

It also allows DVD to ISO conversion, and has a built-in video editor for video customization with features like cropping, trimming, adding effects, and cutting. Besides DVD ripping, UniConverter also provides video conversion to over 1000 formats, video downloading, and transfer options, so it’s an all-in-one media manager.

Compare to MakeMKV, Wondershare UniConverter has more features but with some drawbacks. Let’s see the pros and cons.

How to use Wondershare UniConverter as MakeMKV alternative:

Step 1: Insert the DVD into your computer’s DVD drive, then open Wondershare UniConverter on your computer.

Step 2: On the home interface, click on the Converter module.

Step 3: Click the drop-down icon next to + Add Files/Folder, then Add DVD on the right panel and select the drive where the DVD is inserted.

Step 4: In the DVD Load Model box, select Main Movie or All Movies (All Movies is selected here) and click OK to import the content from the DVD.

Step 5: Click and open the Convert to menu from the bottom, go to the Video tab, select a video format from the list in the left pane, and pick your preferred resolution from the right (MKV with HD 1080P is chosen here for reference).

Step 6: Click on the High-Speed Conversion option in the top-right corner, select your desired output folder in the Save to section, and then hit Convert All to start the DVD conversion process to your chosen format.

VLC Media Player

• OS: Windows 11/10/8.1/8/7/Vista/XP, macOS 10.7 - 13, Linux
• Price: Free

As a substitute for MakeMKV, VLC is an open-source media player that can also rip DVDs and Blu-rays. It’s not your best tool for Blu-ray ripping, but it’s a great video player that supports most video and audio formats.

However, VLC has some limitations. As open-source software, it can’t natively rip encrypted Blu-ray discs. To do this, you need to install additional libraries, which can be a bit of a pain. Even after you’ve done that, the ripping process is slower than other tools, and VLC might struggle with some Blu-ray discs.

Let’s take a look at the pros and cons of VLC Media Player

How to Use VLC Media Player for DVD Ripping:

Step 1: Insert the DVD into your computer’s drive, then open the VLC media player.

Step 2: In VLC, go to the Media menu and select Open Disc. Under the Disc tab, click the Browse... button next to the Disc device to import the DVD content into VLC. Make sure to check the No disc menus box.

Step 3: Click the Play dropdown menu and select Convert. A new window will appear where you can configure the output format and destination folder.

Step 4: From the Profile list, choose Video – H.264 + MP3 (MP4) as the output format. Then, click the Browse button in the Destination section to select where you want to save the converted file.

Step 5: Finally, click the Start button to begin ripping the DVD. VLC will process the DVD, and you can simply wait until the conversion is finished.

Best MakeMKV Alternatives: A Side-by-Side Comparison

Now that we’ve shown you some of the best MakeMKV alternatives, it’s time to compare them side by side. This comparison will help you decide on features, performance, and value, so you can choose the right one for you.

Based on the table above DVDneXtCOPY DVD Ripper is the best MakeMKV alternative. It has everything: high quality, fast speed, strong decryption, and customization for your DVD conversion, it’s an all-in-one software for DVD ripping.

FAQs About MakeMKV Alternative

What is better than MakeMKV?

There are several better alternatives to MakeMKV, including DVDneXtCOPY DVD Ripper, HandBrake, WinX DVD Ripper Platinum, Wondershare UniConverter, and VLC Media Player. Among these, DVDFab DVD Ripper stands out for its advanced customization, built-in editor, and support for encrypted DVDs.

Is HandBrake better than MakeMKV?

Yes, HandBrake can be considered better than MakeMKV in many scenarios. While MakeMKV focuses on lossless ripping to MKV format only, HandBrake supports multiple output formats. It also includes built-in device presets for iPhone, iPad, Apple TV, Android, and more, as well as customization options. However, note that HandBrake cannot bypass copy protection on DVDs.

Can you use MakeMKV for free?

Yes, you can use MakeMKV for free while it's in beta. However, you’ll need to update the MakeMKV beta key approximately every 30 days.

How long does it take to rip a DVD with MakeMKV?

The time it takes to rip a DVD depends on the content. For discs with little content or short movies, it can be 5-10 minutes. For longer movies or discs with a lot of bonus content, it can be 45 minutes or more.

Does MakeMKV remove DRM protection?

Yes, MakeMKV can rip most region-coded DVDs, but not all of them. It can remove DRM protection from Blu-ray discs such as AACS and BD+. But, for other popular DVD copy protection like Sony ARccOS, UOPs, RCE, Disney X-project DRM, you need another option than MakeMKV.

Conclusion

MakeMKV is a good option for ripping DVDs, a free and simple way to convert discs to MKV. But it has limitations: slower speed and limited format support. If you want a more complete solution with faster speed, broader format support and more customization options, MakeMKV alternatives like DVDneXtCOPY DVD Ripper are much better. When it comes to functionality and versatility, DVDneXtCOPY and similar tools are way ahead of MakeMKV.